The word on the street
Tuesday, October 26, 2004 by 141NYC
Are we nearing the end of the era of the institutional church? This seems to be a prevalent question, floating around in many different places. You see the question being raised on blogs, message boards, and certainly in private conversations all around the Christian world. I don't really read the mainstream Christian publications, but as far as I know, they are not addressing this issue. So why is it the word on the street?
The church has always served a certain purpose in whatever era it has been present in. Obviously, during the New Testament times the church was a radical new phenomenon. Many people talk about returning to the early church way of doing things, but that is simply impossible. That incarnation of the church is no longer appropriate for today's society. Of course there are elements that we can take and learn from. But simply defering to the past is not the answer.
The early church became irrelevant when church and state became partners. Some see this as a great apostasy. I believe it was simply a movement appropriate to the situation. Of course, the imperial church experience points both high and low, and the state church remained in power for many years. But once again, society changed and the pendulum had to swing.
I don't think I need to recount the entire course of church history here. Suffice it to say, in recent history there was a great movement that I will call the "evangelical era." This is just for classification purposes, by the way. Anyway, the force by which this movement drove forward is beginning to wane, and the cautious observer can see it quite clearly. Why is this happening?
One only needs to look at the rest of society to see why. The postmoderns, Gen-X or whatever you want to call them are taking their places in the major roles in society. They (meaning us as I include myself) are essentially inheriting a world without hope, a world without direction. We are bombarded with messages from all sides, yet have learned through painful experience to trust no one. We no longer believe in the power of institutions to positively affect the world around us. We would like it to be that way, but recognize the futility of this suggestion in a chaotic and often senseless world. Rationality, the crown jewel of previous generations, has left us a world of pollution, violence and injustice. We have been stabbed in the back by the people we trusted, plain and simple.
Therefore, an institution that offers a simple solution to the problems of the world hold little attraction. Some rally around other causes: politics, the environment, social justice. The world is so desperately hurting and we want to see the hurt go away. We just simply don't know where to begin.
Does the pendulum need to start swinging again? It certainly needs to. Our society today will no longer accept a neatly arranged identity, a complete paradigm guaranteed to cure our ills. Ours is a hermeneutics of suspicion, galvanized by years of deceit and broken promises. We are not longer looking for answers, we are just looking for a starting point. After we find it, we'll take it from there.
If there is a paralell need between us and the early church, it is the need for hope. Christianity is a faith based on hope, communicated through love. But if we believe that, are we willing to live out its incarnation in a broken and suspicious society? That is the challenge that awaits us, a challenge many miles beyond the simple days of yore, beyond the frivolous concerns of church growth.
The church has always served a certain purpose in whatever era it has been present in. Obviously, during the New Testament times the church was a radical new phenomenon. Many people talk about returning to the early church way of doing things, but that is simply impossible. That incarnation of the church is no longer appropriate for today's society. Of course there are elements that we can take and learn from. But simply defering to the past is not the answer.
The early church became irrelevant when church and state became partners. Some see this as a great apostasy. I believe it was simply a movement appropriate to the situation. Of course, the imperial church experience points both high and low, and the state church remained in power for many years. But once again, society changed and the pendulum had to swing.
I don't think I need to recount the entire course of church history here. Suffice it to say, in recent history there was a great movement that I will call the "evangelical era." This is just for classification purposes, by the way. Anyway, the force by which this movement drove forward is beginning to wane, and the cautious observer can see it quite clearly. Why is this happening?
One only needs to look at the rest of society to see why. The postmoderns, Gen-X or whatever you want to call them are taking their places in the major roles in society. They (meaning us as I include myself) are essentially inheriting a world without hope, a world without direction. We are bombarded with messages from all sides, yet have learned through painful experience to trust no one. We no longer believe in the power of institutions to positively affect the world around us. We would like it to be that way, but recognize the futility of this suggestion in a chaotic and often senseless world. Rationality, the crown jewel of previous generations, has left us a world of pollution, violence and injustice. We have been stabbed in the back by the people we trusted, plain and simple.
Therefore, an institution that offers a simple solution to the problems of the world hold little attraction. Some rally around other causes: politics, the environment, social justice. The world is so desperately hurting and we want to see the hurt go away. We just simply don't know where to begin.
Does the pendulum need to start swinging again? It certainly needs to. Our society today will no longer accept a neatly arranged identity, a complete paradigm guaranteed to cure our ills. Ours is a hermeneutics of suspicion, galvanized by years of deceit and broken promises. We are not longer looking for answers, we are just looking for a starting point. After we find it, we'll take it from there.
If there is a paralell need between us and the early church, it is the need for hope. Christianity is a faith based on hope, communicated through love. But if we believe that, are we willing to live out its incarnation in a broken and suspicious society? That is the challenge that awaits us, a challenge many miles beyond the simple days of yore, beyond the frivolous concerns of church growth.

